"I have not ever read or seen any Sci-Fi or Twilight or Star wars material that comes close to this book as far as intellectual quality"

"This book is so deep and cosmic. I have not ever read or seen any Sci-Fi or Twilight or Star wars material that comes close to this book as far as intellectual quality and it is so imaginatively layered that it would take a genius to put it together.  And, if it was put together by a human being, then how come this person is not a writer for Hollywood or something like that?"

-- DeNnaceTheMeNaCE

"...is my favorite book of all time!!!"

"...its a great fucking book. If this is a relatively a beginning look in to aliens, i would not get this book. I would first learn how this planet is being controlled. Read William Coopers, Behold A Pale Horse, then Gods of Eden. Once you learn that religion was written (encouraged) by aliens, then get this book. This book in words, ties the strings. But you first need the strings to tie. If not, then you just throw the book aside as a fake..but i promise you..its not..wish it wasnt.. 10/10 for book...if it is true, is a book that EVERY person on this planet should read and follow more than any other. After studying aliens for years. Stumbling into his... gives me the fucking chills... and is my favorite book of all time!!!"

-- logic2reason

"I have read this book and I highly recommend it."

"I have read this book and I highly recommend it. The end was quite clever and the overall story was great!  All in all...great stuff for open-minded truth searchers like David Icke, Jim Marrs,and Alex Jones etc.."

-- sarasweet85

"Blown away"

"I read the entire book in one sitting and was truly "blown away."  Everything seems to be accurate, and it does not seem to be a hoax.  I thought it was important to bring it to the attention of (other readers). This book is essentially the transcripts of a nurse who communicated with the one surviving alien following the crash at Roswell in 1947. I have been trying to verify the identity of the nurse using genealogical resources, but so far no luck. Her name was changed, she said, when she was relocated. Anyone have any feedback on this amazing story?  Lawrence Spencer does an excellent job of trying to verify all relevant facts, etc., with extensive footnotes."

-- Mookite (e-mail)

"...filling the glaring holes in present cosmology".

"Thank you for bringing us this wonderful gift of perspective. The face of it is, and always will be, for noisy debates, but for those who can see the treasure, its quantum triangulation is precise.  Predictably this lot would discard the diamond while fighting over its box. The discrete term “Is Be” is the assayer’s certificate for the material’s authenticity.  Over most heads, but nonetheless a point of fact that locks the cosmological genesis into a very specific dimensional coordinate, filling the glaring holes in present cosmology.  As I’m sure you correctly surmised in your decision to destroy the source material. "

"i can attest to the belieavability in his book."

"...this book is a must read. i had a hard time going along with this, but after reading several other books on the topic, i can attest to the belieavability in his book."

-- RoganSF

"The best 5 bucks I've spent recently"

"The book is available for $5.00 on Lulu.com.  So I bought it. It explains the technology behind "living ships".. Its way simpler than what you thought, very close though.  Its also a technology much more advanced than nano tech..... I wish I just could hand out copies, but that wouldn't be fair.

All I can say is read it. Its the best 5 bucks I've spent recently.... What I know from reading this book, is that I kinda feel peaceful because alot of question about who and what we are have been answered in a reasonable manner.
In my best estimation this seems like the real deal and somehow fits with the alternative history that I have figured out."

-- Brant (blog post)

"This book struck a chord deep inside me. "

"This book struck a chord deep inside me.  Put me on a list if it is forming."

-- Ezy Blackbear (e-mail)

"It will put so much understanding into your life."

"Read Alien Interview:  It will put so much understanding into your life."

-- UpRiver (forum post)

"This book is truly a mind-blower and takes the cake on the most far-out UFO-related book I've read..."

"This book is truly a mind-blower and takes the cake on the most far-out UFO-related book I've read, even surpassing "The Mothman Prophecies" by John A. Keel.  How true can this story be? Can any of it be true? If it's truth wrapped in lies, what's the purpose? Whoever sent the stuff to Spencer isn't getting rich from this and won't. They won't be famous either. It's much like the MJ-12 documents of 1984, which were sent to researchers anonymously, and Spencer points this out in his introduction. Spencer is not a UFO author or a UFO researcher. He is a writer who focuses on esoteric spiritual matters. He is simply passing the info on to us. I really can't justify or understand his reasons for destroying the materials though. That was stupid in my opinion. he claims he didn't want to be hounded by researchers for the rest of his life.

One of the big concerns for me is the fact that this story promotes the New Age religious slant that: we are all "immortal spiritual beings" or "gods" in our own right. There is no god who created anything. All life was created by immortal spiritual beings who inhabit artificial bodies and communicate with us telepathically. These are the religious ideas brought forth by folks like: Madame Blavatsky, Aleister Crowley, Benjamin Creme (Lord Maitreya & Share International) and the like. The thrust being, the god you are looking for is in you...it is you...you are immortal...you are god. Christians aren't going to like it, because it sounds like the "end times deception" of the Revelation to John (the Apocalypse). I am not a religious person. I also am not an atheist. You can call me agnostic if you like, but I'm not sure that applies either. As I've stated elsewhere, I've studied all the major religions of the world and am not sure what to make of it all. I do have some theories, but I keep them private. It's my choice. My life philosophy is simple: "Never completely discount the improbable." Make of it what you will. I have had the suspicion for a couple of decades that the next big religion will be related to the UFO problem and I have tried to warn people of it.

The book has elements of many other books already in the public domain: Strieber's books ("Majestic", "Communion", "Transformation", "Breakthrough", "The Grays"); Courtney Brown, PhD's books ("Cosmic Voyage", "Cosmic Explorers"); Corso & Birnes "The Day After Roswell"; Marshall Vian Summers' "The Allies Of Humanity; Nancy Lieder's "Zetatalk" and many others. The information supplied to Spencer could well have been a complete or partial fabrication dreamed up by someone with an intense interest in UFOs. Let's hope so. As far as this particular book goes, read it if it interests you. If it doesn't, I wouldn't worry about it. I am just going to mentally file it with the other catch-all books in my collection, that have no confirmation of any sort attached to them, but I can tell you it was an interesting read."

-- D. Robinson  (MySpace post)

"...potentially explosive if true and outstanding science fiction if not"

I have read this book and have , for the moment, to would put it into the "potentially explosive if true and outstanding science fiction if not" category.

Other observations;Trust and honesty seems to be commented on by the "Alien" yet if you apply the same standard to the revelations in this book as they have been "Telepathed" , then it could also be a dishonest viewpoint by the 'Alien' to sway the recipient and subsequently the reader to another allegiance. Readers will perhaps fully understand my viewpoint when the author's final notes are read.

I have read countless books and have a good library of works relating to UFO's and Aliens because the subject interests me greatly. I have cross linked some of the contents of the book by just looking at other works in my library and while I cannot deny what is said is profound, I believe the Editor of the Book made the correct decision with his disclaimer at the beginning. The editor has also wisely refrained from any ending editorial summary comment and has extensive footnotes for cross reference purposes.

Reading thru the footnotes once again it adds little to any doubt I have that the US Military/Government did recover a disc at Roswell. Of that incident I am in no doubt now after all these years. The question is - " if Agenda's of the CIA, FBI and Military Industrial complex, act to protect the public from the 'shocking truth', while exploiting any back engineered technology for their own misdeeds, it indeed suggest bigger more insidious hand is moving the puppet, and it is in this light that I choose not to decry the contents of this book.

In final summation, I can say that if offers an interesting interpretation of our history on Earth and an alternate view of actual realities as perceived by current interpretations."

Annonymous -- Above Top Secret

"The alien does not care about what the military people want..."

"I just read the book of what is allegedly transcripts from actual examination of the only alien being that survived the Roswell crash. The alien does not care about what the military people want and refuses to speak to anyone but the nurse...in the end it is revealed why which also ties in with info Alex Collier has shared about beings trapped on this planet for many thousands of years which actually came from higher dimensions but was so unfortunate as to be killed on a mission here. This aliens vision of what Earth is about also resonnates with what was shared by a socalled Elite insider on a forum a while ago."

-- Sanat: Project Avalon Forum

"I am personally inclined to take this lady's story more seriously than most alien reports."

"These are the same conclusions I reached independently via 20 years of research into mankind's religions. I wrote three books about them, "The Division of Consciousness", "The Lost secret of Death", and "Original Christianity". As shown at divisiontheory.org
I am personally inclined to take this lady's story more seriously than most alien reports, due to this connection alone."

-- Peter Novak

(Author of The Division of Consciousness,  The Lost Secret of Death, and Original Christianity)

"It left an imprint on me and I couldn't stop reading it."

"I just read everything but the footnotes, those I skimmed, and it is intriguing. I have many q's about what others think. So if this is a work of fiction it was done really well and was very entertaining. It felt eerily like it could be the real thing, however.

For argument's sake I was curious whether anyone else agrees that of course the alien, Airl, would depict herself and The Domain to be the greater good of entity's in the universe, seeing as they are practicing a "Manifest Destiny" of sorts in their trek through our galaxy and the universe. (Everyone always thinks they are right, otherwise there would not be war.) Her fellow IS-BE's and The Domain do definitely seem more benevolent than the Old Empire who in essence threw us out like garbage and imprisoned us on Earth with no foreseen way of escape. (Good times!!) In our hypnotized state of existence we toil away in our flesh bodies making the best of things.

So what of the Peleidians who are supposedly trying to help us free ourselves there is no mention of them? She actually seems to suggest that they are part of the Old Empire. She never really said the name Peleidian but did talk of the "Mystery" of the pyramids and don't the Peleidians claim they will some day "turn them back on?"

I thought the Peleidians were the good guys, and the greys with doll bodies were the bad guys?

I will say it left an imprint on me and I couldn't stop reading it. While skimming the footnotes I decided that I wanted to take what I wanted from the main read and not muss it up by conjecture. It was definitely a fun read that I plan on passing onto the few friends I have that will enjoy reading it as fiction.

If it does have any truth to it I will have done my duty by passing it on."

-- Anyone (forum post)

"There is more truth in that interview, than most would care to admit!"

"That alien said this is all a big mindf...k. We are eternal souls but when we die on this planet there is this mechanism that captures us, wipes out the memory and sends us back here, basically it's a prison planet.  There is more truth in that interview, than most would care to admit!!"

-- Forum post on Godlikeproductions

"I am convinced that the material given to Mrs. O'Donnell is genuine."

I read the book, "Alien Interview" and I was surprised to have incredible similarities to encounters with studies by Dr. Corrado Malanga, which conducts research on alien interference from more than 30 years. His technique is mainly the regressive hypnosis.

Many points into the manuscripts of Mrs. O'Donnell are the same as discovered by doctor Malanga, while others are a little different, as for example, the reason for the persons are abduced.  It seems that the main reason is that removing the energy to the immortals spirits, I do not know if he also clears the memory.

In each case, the immortals spirits, into the deep hypnosis, seems to not have a long memory, the opposite of what you might think of an immortal entity.  Perhaps this memory erasure program exists.  According to the theory of Dr. Malanga, who studied hundreds of cases of abduction, various aliens operating in this field, trying to finally capture the immortal spirits, because at the moment, they return to the human biological body.

I am convinced that the material given to Mrs. O'Donnell is genuine, I do not believe it to be a coincidence.

Best regards

Rud Skall

"I would caution against dismissing this material as fiction."

"I would caution against dismissing this material as fiction, especially those who authoritatively believe in a specific God as their faith is merely that. The text is clearly the work of a skilled author; whether that original author was a Mrs. MacElroy or Lawrence R. Spencer remains to be exhaustively analyzed, debated and digested... and -as already indicated- even then the truth may not be discerned.

I am reminded of another author, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle who crafted a fictional character named Sherlock Holmes. The reality of that personae too, has been debated for nearly 100 years and continues to this day. I'm sure I will enjoy this new tome as much as I've enjoyed Doyle's over the years."

-- gsbltd (forum post)

"I enjoyed it and appreciated the perspective it added to my view of existence."

"I listened to your interview the other day with Jeff Rense and then bought the book and read it in one sitting.  I enjoyed it and appreciated the perspective it added to my view of existence."

Michael Sparrow (e-mail)

"...cosmic version of what happens here on earth."

"I've read about 90 pages of the book. Good stuff. The alien talks about 'duties' and 'service' and 'conquest'. I'm thinking - this does not sound like a free society. It just sounds like a large, cosmic version of what happens here on earth. Big guy goes to war and defeats little guy. Now the peasants pay taxes and are slaves to the new master."

-- Anonymous forum post

"It could happen...."

" For all I now, the whole thing could be a big hoax, but what if it were really true? What the alien said about earth being a "prison planet" and that we are old souls is so true. Just think about it anyway.... It could happen.... "

-- Robert M. Spencer

"I was glued to the book for 6 hours reading it."

" I've heard some pretty wild conspiracy theories but this probably is the only one that truly disturbed me. However, I was glued to the book for 6 hours reading it. It definitely kept my attention and it was a good book. So I decided to put my emotions aside and rate the book based purely on it's entertainment value. "

-- S. Holmes

"Amazing..."

"This interview is mind blowing stuff. It's just confirming thoughts that I've had about life the universe and the meaning of it all. I've always thought I myself am a 'slice' of god just like everyone else. we are all eternal all-knowing all-powerful beings just trying to experience the game of life in order to keep ourselves from getting bored.

Maybe the amnesia machine is the cause of childhood amnesia! Wwe all have childhood amnesia, but nobody really knows 100% why? we just assume it's because the brain isn't developed.   Amazing... I've always felt like I've incarnated into my body forgetting my previous lives just to experience life from the eyes of the person I'm incarnating as. I always thought when I die, I will choose another body to experience life as (maybe even a starving child born into poverty). I'm saddened by this news that I imprisoned on earth and cannot experience the rest of what the universe has to offer."

-- Anonymous forum post

"I couldn't stop reading it"

"I decided to download the book last night and read a few pages, just to feel it out.... wow. I couldn't stop reading it. I finally had to turn out the light and hit the bed but I got about halfway through it and I found it to be extremely interesting. My gut-instinct tells me that this is complete BS as far as it didn't actually come from an extraterrestrial interview but so far, I'm finding most of it to be pretty well thought-out. I've heard a lot of this stuff before so it's not as if all of it is newly-discovered information. But it's a nicely-developed theory... probably took a good while to get all this stuff together and hammered out. I found what I've read so far to be incredibly interesting but as I read, I kept thinking of that guy who talks about the giant 'soul-collector' on the moon. Was that Lear? A lot of this really seemed to align itself with the crap they've had on coast-to-coast over the years. This is a great piece of entertainment, in all sincerity.... I'll probably buy the book at some point. I'm going to read the other half of it later on today. Should be fun."

-- Paracast forum post

"Fascinating"

"I've been reading this book and perhaps the (author) is playing some kind of a game on the level of a pseudonymous prankster.
The book is certainly imaginative, I'll give him that. Imaginative in the extreme and actually quite entertaining. Whoever wrote it is obviously well read in the literary traditions of romanticism. I expect that this tale will become a new part of UFO conspiracy folklore. In fact, perhaps the author's goal is to contribute to UFO folklore. Fascinating."

-- Paracast forum post

"FORMER NASA astronaut and moon-walker Dr Edgar Mitchell has stunningly claimed aliens exist!"

"And he says extra-terrestrials have visited Earth on several occasions - but the alien contact has been repeatedly covered up by governments for six decades. Dr Mitchell, 77, said during a radio interview that sources at the space agency who had had contact with aliens described the beings as 'little people who look strange to us.' He said supposedly real-life ET's were similar to the traditional image of a small frame, large eyes and head. Chillingly, he claimed our technology is "not nearly as sophisticated" as theirs and "had they been hostile", he warned "we would be been gone by now".

Check out this new book http://alieninterview.org/ You really, really must read it.

-- gauharjk (blog post)

( Editor's Note:  Check out statements made by astronauts and cosmonauts about alien activities:  ASTRONAUTS TESTIMONY )

"After hearing a talk-radio interview with the editor of this book I was left both intrigued and slightly miffed by the end of it.

Intrigued because in this era of CGI and Photoshop - image analysis simply leads to more of the mundane, looped discussion about "real" or "hoax" so contact testimony is, in my experience, both more valuable and more interesting. I also despaired somewhat because this information, if accurate [and since reading it I believe it is], should have come out decades ago not on the deathbed of the Army nurse who provided it.

In addition to the communication from the pilot extra-terrestrial from the Roswell crash itself, both Lawrence Spencer and Matilda O'Donnell MacElroy provide various useful contexts for the bizarre and often metaphysical journey the notes take the reader on. Believe me when I suggest that the information the book contains is so explosive that readers need this wrap around commentary to ground them as they work through the details.

I suppose the information is *only* dramatic if you have a background in this area. As Matilda mentions in the opening letter to Spencer - if the information was presented to the mainstream press and many other outlets it would just be laughed at or avoided due to to fear of breaking the now outdated 'National Security State' taboo. If however you have come across the Gnostic idea or indeed have examined the contactee database for versions of our species galactic history and evolution - you'll probably be equipped to enter the reality of the Roswell ET and the information she [it had a female presence according to the Army nurse] provides. The real question is do you want to?

Without giving much away - much of the information we find resonates on a deep level. It feels genetic and holographic. A lot clicks into place when we learn for example [and here's the Gnostic element - the Gnostics thought the human race have been caught in a prison of matter and/or materialism] that Earth has been used as a dumping ground by a huge ET race who came before the alliance the Roswell ET belongs to. This 'prison planet' means we have two polarities of characters: both 'criminal' types no-one wants and numerous artists and political dissidents who were moved here for failing to pull along with the big-brother type organization this dominant, space-faring group have developed in the wider galactic scheme of things.

This book is one of a kind. Most will not be interested, others will avoid due to the complexities it throws up - the rest of us can learn from what we find - but it will hit you on an almost visceral level."

-- David Griffin, Exopolitics Institute

"The real deal"

"Very likely the real deal... If it is real, then the powers that be will have their minions pan it, misrepresent it and use their considerable talents to bring it down hard. The true nature of this work has been ignored. It is what it says, the transcript of an interview with the survivor of the 1947 Roswell crash. It is this part that has the feel of veracity. Is it the author's work of fiction? I think not. "

-- Daniel Davis

"...it rings true with much of what I've read about Roswell AND the secrecy behind who we are."

"Personally, for me, it rings true with much of what I've read about Roswell AND the secrecy behind who we are. It may well be a carefully-crafted work of fiction, but whoever put it together has tied in pretty much everything I agree with regarding our origins and I give them full credit for doing that.

The book validates several things Dr Greer has said, especially:
- the Roswell craft was brought down by an electromagnetic disturbance (shot down?) and like Dr Greer said on the recent Paracast interview, it doesn't matter how advanced they are, their craft was not infallible and was designed for the rigours of space itself, not specifically for handling earth conditions or unforseen circumstances.
- the ETs were concerned about the development of atomic technology and the environmental impact it would have on the Earth and all life on it.
- the importance of telepathy to not only communicate interpersonally, but to pilot the craft itself. Paracast honchos would undoubtedly scoff at such nonsensical folly, but Ralph Ring (interviewed on ATS Mix not that long ago) described an experiment where people controlled a craft and destination with solely their minds.
- Airl openly invited reverse-engineering of the Roswell craft for the implementation of future technology.
- Airl is benevolent, but unfortunately Earth's inhabitants are still locked into the slave race mentality set up by our less benevolent ancient rulers.
- the enslavement of the people and the idea of banking and war weapons (military industrial complex) to continually keep the human race beaten down and keep them from advancing spiritually.

This also ties in with the research of David Icke, for example:
- secrecy has been maintained to hide our true origins
- the idea of God was a fabrication, an illusion, a misdirection to prevent us from being our own gods (to be 'free'). According to Airl, a person who believes in God is less likely to take responsibility for their own lives and more likely to fit in a slave prison system and not question / remember / recall their previous lives and the mind-wipe sting operation that goes on each time the spirit leaves the body.
- 'mysteries' were created to misguide us; large structures such as the Pyramids were erected to mislead us into a world of astronomical / mystical mumbo jumbo and reinforce a belief in Earthly material objects and possessions that last for eternity, rather than our spirits which are eternal and infinite. The ancients were attempting to suppress the idea of a spiritual self without mass - achieved by accentuating physicality and materiality, and shroud it all in deliberately-unsolvable mystique.
- interestingly though, Airl says that the reptile and serpent mythology was adopted to mislead and throw us 'off-track' - the creatures themselves were not reptilian. So, David, if you're reading this, look into the possibility that all the reptilian stuff was a cover too - just like every other mystery you've exposed.

Airl also reminds me a lot of Rael, she backs up the notion that all humans and creatures on this planet were genetically engineered by teams and certain orgainisations were competitively involved in populating the Earth over trillions of years. Once again, the Paracast people should be aghast that they would remotely connect themselves vicariously with such an absurd cultist fringe element!! The notion of infinity, promoted by Rael, is prevalent in Airl's words; the humanoid form has always been around in various forms, since the universe has been around. Airl scoffs at the idea of evolution, but creation has always been intelligently designed, not by a 'god' but by certain classes of IS-BEs.

It also tallies with Bob Dean and Marcia Schafer's testimony on Project Camelot - that they can recall past lives somewhere in the dark recesses of their minds. Not saying I believe the account; but as a story regarding the history of the earth and secrets of the universe, I have no problem with it at all."

RiotComing -- Above Top Secret

-- Nestingwave

"My grandfather’s homestead is underneath the Ft. Peck Reservoir"

"I bought the download from LULU.com, after seeing craft last night over LA…I was excited this morning…so I usually check Rense.com to see if anything was seen…I found your interview…and was astounded to see the woman was from Glasgow MT…that is where I am from…my father was in the Air Force stationed in Glasgow where he met my Mom. My grandfather’s homestead is underneath the Ft Peck Reservoir, he helped construct the dam before he went overseas to fight in Europe, that dam brought the region out of the depression.

I have read Pagell’s Gnostic books, and I am also a third degree Master Mason, my father was a Roscrucian for thirty years before he died. I am well into the manuscript and I find some things like word usage and the archduke Ferdinand a bit unusual…but whatever.  As I read this, it rings of the Mormon belief that you inherit your own planet and become a god, and the Rosicrucian belief in reincarnation. Lastly the idea that lower gods rule us in a prison on Earth is the Gnostic belief.  I also have a feeling that a disciple of Sitchin may be at the source of this.  I am waiting to see if they will describe the universe as electrically charged. As far a California is concerned, if I apply the Domain theory to it, I would say it is the most diverse and perverse place around, if any one group in the world is trying to break out of the prison consciously, I would say it happens here. I love LA."

-- Jeff C. Cook   (e-mail)

"The attached video provides extensive evidence..."

"The attached video provides extensive evidence that the content of the transcripts provided by Matilda MacElroy may be accurate.  The video is especially interesting because it includes interviews with many high ranking military officers, astronauts and information from authoritative sources, including the late Lt. Philip Corso who wrote the book, "The Day After Roswell".

-- bidid2349  (e-mail)

Editor Footnote:  Read what many astronauts have to say about their own encounters with aliens: ASTRONAUT TESTIMONIES

"Maybe this world is another planet's hell."

  - Aldous Huxley, (26 July 1894 – 22 November 1963) writer, humanist and pacifist, but was also latterly interested in spiritual subjects such as parapsychology and philosophical mysticism. Author of, Brave New World. 

Could be very informative or all bunkum

"Re: Alien Interview book --

"The only problem with this one is that someone could come along and just make this stuff up. It does sell books. Considering that the author of this book is a fiction writer, it doesn't help the cause for validity.  Could be an interesting book! One can always make one's mind up about it - AFTER having read it. Could be very informative or all bunkum, who knows? "

-- Helen Dagner (forum post)

A connection MacElroy and Roddenberry?

"I read Chris Knowles’ Secreg Sun web site and he did a recent story about Gene Roddenberry and possible esoteric connections with the “Council of Nine” (The number nine itself has occult value attached to it) :

In early 1975, a broke and depressed Roddenberry was approached by a British former race car driver named Sir John Whitmore, who was associated with a strange organization called ‘Lab-9.’ Though unknown to the public, Lab-9 were ostensibly a sort of an independent version of the X-Files, dedicated to the research of paranormal phenomena. However, Lab-9 had another, more complex agenda- they later claimed to be in contact with a group of extraterrestrials called the ‘Council of Nine’ or simply ‘The Nine’, who had been communicating through ‘channelers’ or psychic mediums.

The Nine claimed to be the creators of mankind, and had informed the channelers that they would be returning to Earth soon. Lab-9 had wanted to hire Roddenberry to write a screenplay based on the Council of Nine’s imminent return. To help Roddenberry in his research, Lab-9 flew him out to their headquarters, located on a large estate in Ossining, NY. There, Roddenberry met and interviewed several psychics, and prepared the groundwork for his script.

Now given the supposed ‘telepathic’ abilities of the “Domain” and this “Council of Nine”, could there be a connection between the two ‘organizations’ and the now deceased MacElroy and Roddenberry? Did one influence the other? If so, how? A more fundamental issue arising out of this is “Is there such a thing as mental telepathy?” Can we speak to each other and creatures from other places by thought alone?"

-- Dad2059 (blog post)

Was he speaking English?

"Here’s the latest scam I’ve found: “Alien Interview: Top secret transcripts from Roswell”. That’s right, for the small fee of 18$ for a paperback, you get:

' the complete and unedited top secret transcripts of a series of interviews with an alien survivor of the notorious Roswell UFO crash conducted at the Roswell Army Air Field.'

I really have nothing else to say about this, it’s just funny to even consider an Alien interview. Was he speaking English? Anyway, have a quick look!"

-- Ben (blog post)

"...obviously didn't do his homework..."

"Mr. Spencer obviously didn't do his homework before consenting to sign his  name as the author.  This tale, allegedly from a Roswell witness, by the  name of Matilda O'Donnell MacElroy does not hold up to scrutiny.  Mr. Spencer  admittedly never met this person and only had a 20 minute phone conversation  with her 10 years ago wherein Ms. MacElroy refused to comment on anything  relating to the Roswell incident.  Low and behold, 10 years later Mr.  Spencer claims he received a package (which he says he destroyed, so no  evidence remains) of documents and transcripts allegedly from Matilda  O'Donnel MacElroy but even Mr. Spencer can not verify the author and all  attempts he made resulted in no such person exists. But more importantly, he  claims Ms. MacElroy to be "Senior Master Sergeant  Women's Army Air Force Medical Corp, Retired, 509th Bomb Group, Roswell, New  Mexico" and boldly states so on the cover of the book. The rank of "senor master sergeant" didn't exist in 1947 and the Army Air Force went out of  existence September 1947 . There is no way possible that Ms. MacElroy (even  if she did exist) could have retired from a non-existent military group.  I wouldn't waste one minute reading this book or giving the contents any  credibility what so ever.  Consider it another well crafted psyop perpetrated by the massive propaganda machine already in place which wants  people to fear aliens."

-- Sojourner (forum post)

(Editor Note:  Obviously, "Sojourner" didn't read the the book, much less the letter, carefully. If one actually reads the book, including the footnotes, one  would know that these apparent discrepancies resolve themselves in the larger context of the material.  The Editor did not write the material.  Therefore, all statements made by Mrs. MacElroy are her own, made for whatever reasons she had for making them.  Further, nowhere in the letters or notes does Mrs. MacElroy state the date at which she retired from military service. And, one must take for granted that she intentionally did not use her real name in the letters, for purposes of confidentiality, and for similar reasons may make other anomalous assertions.  Indeed, the entire content of the documents she provided are subject to scrutiny and question.   Your guesses are as good as mine.)